diff --git a/cockatrice/src/tab_game.cpp b/cockatrice/src/tab_game.cpp
index aa2b59922..796659112 100644
--- a/cockatrice/src/tab_game.cpp
+++ b/cockatrice/src/tab_game.cpp
@@ -600,27 +600,16 @@ void TabGame::replayNextEvent()
 
 void TabGame::replayFinished()
 {
-    replayStartButton->setEnabled(true);
-    replayPauseButton->setEnabled(false);
-    replayFastForwardButton->setEnabled(false);
+    replayPlayButton->setChecked(false);
 }
 
-void TabGame::replayStartButtonClicked()
+void TabGame::replayPlayButtonToggled(bool checked)
 {
-    replayStartButton->setEnabled(false);
-    replayPauseButton->setEnabled(true);
-    replayFastForwardButton->setEnabled(true);
-
-    timelineWidget->startReplay();
-}
-
-void TabGame::replayPauseButtonClicked()
-{
-    replayStartButton->setEnabled(true);
-    replayPauseButton->setEnabled(false);
-    replayFastForwardButton->setEnabled(false);
-
-    timelineWidget->stopReplay();
+    if (checked) { // start replay
+        timelineWidget->startReplay();
+    } else { // pause replay
+        timelineWidget->stopReplay();
+    }
 }
 
 void TabGame::replayFastForwardButtonToggled(bool checked)
@@ -1710,26 +1699,24 @@ void TabGame::createReplayDock()
     connect(timelineWidget, SIGNAL(replayFinished()), this, SLOT(replayFinished()));
     connect(timelineWidget, &ReplayTimelineWidget::rewound, messageLog, &ChatView::clearChat);
 
-    replayStartButton = new QToolButton;
-    replayStartButton->setIconSize(QSize(32, 32));
-    replayStartButton->setIcon(QPixmap("theme:replay/start"));
-    connect(replayStartButton, SIGNAL(clicked()), this, SLOT(replayStartButtonClicked()));
-    replayPauseButton = new QToolButton;
-    replayPauseButton->setIconSize(QSize(32, 32));
-    replayPauseButton->setEnabled(false);
-    replayPauseButton->setIcon(QPixmap("theme:replay/pause"));
-    connect(replayPauseButton, SIGNAL(clicked()), this, SLOT(replayPauseButtonClicked()));
+    replayPlayButton = new QToolButton;
+    replayPlayButton->setIconSize(QSize(32, 32));
+    QIcon playButtonIcon = QIcon();
+    playButtonIcon.addPixmap(QPixmap("theme:replay/start"), QIcon::Normal, QIcon::Off);
+    playButtonIcon.addPixmap(QPixmap("theme:replay/pause"), QIcon::Normal, QIcon::On);
+    replayPlayButton->setIcon(playButtonIcon);
+    replayPlayButton->setCheckable(true);
+    connect(replayPlayButton, SIGNAL(toggled(bool)), this, SLOT(replayPlayButtonToggled(bool)));
+
     replayFastForwardButton = new QToolButton;
     replayFastForwardButton->setIconSize(QSize(32, 32));
-    replayFastForwardButton->setEnabled(false);
     replayFastForwardButton->setIcon(QPixmap("theme:replay/fastforward"));
     replayFastForwardButton->setCheckable(true);
     connect(replayFastForwardButton, SIGNAL(toggled(bool)), this, SLOT(replayFastForwardButtonToggled(bool)));
 
     replayControlLayout = new QHBoxLayout;
     replayControlLayout->addWidget(timelineWidget, 10);
-    replayControlLayout->addWidget(replayStartButton);
-    replayControlLayout->addWidget(replayPauseButton);
+    replayControlLayout->addWidget(replayPlayButton);
     replayControlLayout->addWidget(replayFastForwardButton);
 
     replayControlWidget = new QWidget();
diff --git a/cockatrice/src/tab_game.h b/cockatrice/src/tab_game.h
index 0c35262cb..655c19e0a 100644
--- a/cockatrice/src/tab_game.h
+++ b/cockatrice/src/tab_game.h
@@ -146,7 +146,7 @@ private:
     int currentReplayStep;
     QList<int> replayTimeline;
     ReplayTimelineWidget *timelineWidget;
-    QToolButton *replayStartButton, *replayPauseButton, *replayFastForwardButton;
+    QToolButton *replayPlayButton, *replayFastForwardButton;
 
     CardFrame *cardInfo;
     PlayerListWidget *playerListWidget;
@@ -220,8 +220,7 @@ signals:
 private slots:
     void replayNextEvent();
     void replayFinished();
-    void replayStartButtonClicked();
-    void replayPauseButtonClicked();
+    void replayPlayButtonToggled(bool checked);
     void replayFastForwardButtonToggled(bool checked);
 
     void incrementGameTime();