diff --git a/cockatrice/src/client/ui/widgets/printing_selector/printing_selector_card_overlay_widget.cpp b/cockatrice/src/client/ui/widgets/printing_selector/printing_selector_card_overlay_widget.cpp
index 64f8b120c..0bc6830af 100644
--- a/cockatrice/src/client/ui/widgets/printing_selector/printing_selector_card_overlay_widget.cpp
+++ b/cockatrice/src/client/ui/widgets/printing_selector/printing_selector_card_overlay_widget.cpp
@@ -177,14 +177,13 @@ void PrintingSelectorCardOverlayWidget::customMenu(QPoint point)
     if (preferredProviderId.isEmpty() || preferredProviderId != cardProviderId) {
         QAction *setPreferred = preferenceMenu->addAction(tr("Set as preferred printing"));
         connect(setPreferred, &QAction::triggered, this, [this, cardProviderId]() {
-            SettingsCache::instance().cardOverrides().setCardPreferenceOverride(rootCard->getName(), cardProviderId,
-                                                                                true);
+            SettingsCache::instance().cardOverrides().setCardPreferenceOverride(rootCard->getName(), cardProviderId);
             emit cardPreferenceChanged();
         });
     } else {
         QAction *setUnpreferred = preferenceMenu->addAction(tr("Unset as preferred printing"));
-        connect(setUnpreferred, &QAction::triggered, this, [this]() {
-            SettingsCache::instance().cardOverrides().setCardPreferenceOverride(rootCard->getName(), "", false);
+        connect(setUnpreferred, &QAction::triggered, this, [this, cardProviderId]() {
+            SettingsCache::instance().cardOverrides().deleteCardPreferenceOverride(rootCard->getName());
             emit cardPreferenceChanged();
         });
     }
diff --git a/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.cpp b/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.cpp
index 3d5b62f59..0bcdcf5e5 100644
--- a/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.cpp
+++ b/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.cpp
@@ -5,16 +5,17 @@ CardOverrideSettings::CardOverrideSettings(QString settingPath, QObject *parent)
 {
 }
 
-void CardOverrideSettings::setCardPreferenceOverride(QString cardName, QString providerId, bool enabled)
+void CardOverrideSettings::setCardPreferenceOverride(const QString &cardName, const QString &providerId)
 {
-    if (enabled) {
-        setValue(providerId, cardName, "cards");
-    } else {
-        deleteValue(providerId, cardName, "cards");
-    }
+    setValue(providerId, cardName, "cards");
 }
 
-QString CardOverrideSettings::getCardPreferenceOverride(QString cardName)
+void CardOverrideSettings::deleteCardPreferenceOverride(const QString &cardName)
+{
+    deleteValue(cardName, "cards");
+}
+
+QString CardOverrideSettings::getCardPreferenceOverride(const QString &cardName)
 {
     return getValue(cardName, "cards").toString();
 }
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.h b/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.h
index 9f0c489eb..1f6b08817 100644
--- a/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.h
+++ b/cockatrice/src/settings/card_override_settings.h
@@ -11,9 +11,11 @@ class CardOverrideSettings : public SettingsManager
     friend class SettingsCache;
 
 public:
-    void setCardPreferenceOverride(QString cardName, QString providerId, bool enabled);
+    void setCardPreferenceOverride(const QString &cardName, const QString &providerId);
 
-    QString getCardPreferenceOverride(QString cardName);
+    void deleteCardPreferenceOverride(const QString &cardName);
+
+    QString getCardPreferenceOverride(const QString &cardName);
 
 private:
     explicit CardOverrideSettings(QString settingPath, QObject *parent = nullptr);